Irony Alert: Coal Plant Shut Down Due to Flooding, Utility Saves Money

June 17, 2019

Science deniers love to wax poetic about the joys of “baseload” coal fired power plants – most of which are old, creaky, and polluting as hell.

Nature, in the form of climate-fueled flooding on the Mississippi, has provided a useful test of that notion.

LaCrosse Tribune (Wisconsin):

Dairyland Power Cooperative took its coal-fired power plant in Genoa offline at the beginning of June to avoid fuel shortages caused by the lack of barges carrying coal up a flooded Mississippi River.

Instead, the La Crosse-headquartered cooperative is purchasing electricity from the Midcontinent Independent System Operator Inc. market to make up for the power normally produced by the plant in Genoa, said Phil Moilien, Dairyland’s vice president.

MISO manages a wholesale electricity market that spans several states in the Midwest, including parts of Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa, Illinois and Missouri.

At face value, buying power from the grid could be cheaper for Dairyland than running its coal plant.

Dairyland’s 345-megawatt coal-fired power plant is one of 17 coal plants in Wisconsin. At 50 years old, it’s the eighth oldest coal-burning power plant in the state.

Record flooding along the Mississippi River, especially in Missouri and Iowa, has delayed commercial barge traffic for months, keeping grain from moving downstream and fertilizers, cement, salt and coal from moving upstream.

Since the Genoa plant, situated along the Mississippi River, gets its coal solely by barge, Moilien said, Dairyland made the decision to temporarily halt operations “not because we are out of coal, but to ensure we have enough coal for the summer months.”

Moilien declined to say how much coal it had stockpiled from the winter, saying the amount was “proprietary.”

Dairyland, as a cooperative, is not required to share its operation and maintenance costs with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. The cooperative declined to say how much it costs to generate power at its Genoa plant.

However, Dairyland reported to the U.S. Energy Information Administration that its fuel cost $27.28 per megawatt-hour in 2017. And it costs about $17 per megawatt-hour to run the power plant, based on EIA modeling. Altogether, that’s a combined cost of about $44 per megawatt-hour to produce electricity at a coal-fired power plant such as Dairyland’s.

By comparison, it costs about $32 per megawatt-hour to buy power from the grid, according to MISO market figures from June 2018.

When the cost of operating a plant exceeds the market price, it’s likely Dairyland could have saved money by buying power in the MISO market instead, said Christina Gosnell, co-founder and president of Catalyst Cooperative. Catalyst collects federal data and builds open-source tools to analyze utility information.

In other words, Gosnell said, “this seems like an expensive plant to run.”

And while Dairyland saves money on fuel costs by buying from the grid, it spends about $14 per megawatt-hour to keep background operations going at the plant, even if the turbine isn’t churning to make power.

It’s surprising they’re operating this plant since, as a cooperative, their goal is to provide the most value for co-op members, Gosnell said.

“Generally, the trend has been that the economics have flipped so that coal plants have become more expensive than they used to be,” said Tom Content, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board, which advocates for “fair, safe and reliable utility service” for customers.

There’s enough power supply in this region that it’s often less expensive to buy, Content said.

4 Responses to “Irony Alert: Coal Plant Shut Down Due to Flooding, Utility Saves Money”

  1. rhymeswithgoalie Says:

    The peak time for grid power use there is winter, right? Or do most people use oil/gas furnaces to heat their homes?

    • dumboldguy Says:

      “Compared to the U.S. average, a greater proportion of Wisconsin residents use natural gas for heating (70%) and a much smaller proportion of residents use electricity (12%)”.

      Click to access WI.pdf

      My brother, who just relocated from NO WI to FL, also used wood pellets for heating. They were cheap because of the large number of paper and lumber mills that produced them as a byproduct—-each fall, a flatbed semi would deliver a load of bagged pellets, which were then stored in the half of the 2-1/2 car garage and every nook and cranny of the basement.

  2. dumboldguy Says:

    Irony indeed—-it gets crazier every day.

    A related aside—-recently became aware that my immediate area in NO VA is known as “Data Center Alley” because 70% of the world’s internet traffic passes through data centers here. They use a rather large amount of electricity, and a significant amount of that electricity comes from coal-fired plants—-that electricity of course being provided by Dominion, the energy company that owns Virginia. Dominion IS going green, though—-working on putting in wind (some day this coming decade) and replacing coal with fracked gas from PA (sooner because it pays off). That gas will be delivered by pipelines through some of the prettiest parts of VA and low-income minority communities. Eminent domain rules in VA.

    One small bit of good news—-the SCOTUS has ruled 6-3 to uphold VA’s ban on uranium mining. The uranium deposits in southern VA are thought to be the largest in the US, and the greedy bastards have been trying to mine them for years.

  3. redskylite Says:

    And yet Trump still tries. . .

    Coal comeback? Trump plan would breathe new life into aging power plants

    Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Andrew Wheeler is scheduled to unveil the final rule of the Trump administration during a news conference Wednesday morning.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: