The Keystone Fixation

December 24, 2014


A mystery. And a clue.

Dan Farber in Legal Planet:

Perseveration is a psychological syndrome where you can’t stop doing something even if the original reason for doing it has vanished.  I’m beginning to wonder if the continuing fervor of Republican support for the project reflects an institutional equivalent of this syndrome.  The economic and political case for the project is fading, but Republicans just can’t seem to let go.

Admittedly, if you put aside the environmental issues, the project was appealing when oil was expensive and consumers were worried about high gas prices.  But today, U.S. oil production is booming, oil is cheap, and gas prices are falling. Yet, Mitch McConnell swears that his first act as Senate majority leader will be to pass a bill approving the Keystone XL pipeline.  It seems like an odd priority given the declining economic and political benefits of the project.

Indeed, there seems to be a good chance that the project won’t be built even if it gets federal approval. As the LA Times reports:

Even at the Manhattan Institute, a free market-oriented think tank with little patience for the arguments made by pipeline opponents, questions are emerging about whether Keystone still deserves star billing in the energy debate.

“I’m for cheap, abundant, reliable energy. Period,” said Robert Bryce, a senior fellow at the conservative group. “This is not ideological. This is about what the economics say.… The project is clearly very challenged right now.”

Some estimates show that the pipeline is already below the breakeven point. The investors bravely say they won’t abandon the project because the price of oil will eventually go up enough to make it worthwhile.  But it doesn’t look like that’s going to happen soon, given that the Saudis are refusing to cut production.  Unconventional oil has brought world prices way down, to the dismay of Vladimir Putin.  Just about the most expensive of the new oil sources comes from oil sands — reportedly about $90 for new projects,  $55 for existing ones.  The price of light sweet crude is now around $55.  So the pipeline looks increasingly dicey in economic terms.  The economically smart decision would probably be to delay the project in order to get a better sense of how prices will shake out.  So don’t be surprised if there’s a substantial delay before construction begins, even assuming it gets congressional approval.

McConnell presumably hopes to get a quick win against the President with this issue in order to build morale. On the other hand, for the same reason, he may have more trouble picking up Democratic Senators for a veto-override. Even if he’s successful, he’s losing the chance to use the opportunity to push for something with more policy and political salience at the beginning of the session.  There’s also the risk of looking foolish for making such a big deal about the pipeline if the project is cancelled or delayed past the next election. Overall, it still seems peculiar that Republicans seem to be so fixated on the issue.

“Inside the Koch Brother’s Toxic Empire” – Rolling Stone:

Over the past dozen years, (Koch Industries) has quietly acquired leases for 1.1 million acres of Alberta oil fields, an area larger than Rhode Island. By some estimates, Koch’s direct holdings nearly double ExxonMobil’s and nearly triple Shell’s. In May, Koch Oil Sands Operating LLC of Calgary, Alberta, sought permits to embark on a multi-billion­dollar tar-sands-extraction operation. This one site is projected to produce 22 million barrels a year – more than a full day’s supply of U.S. oil.


One Response to “The Keystone Fixation”

  1. dumboldguy Says:

    A good post—-it’s surprising that no one has commented on it, considering the uncounted hours many of us have spent on the topic over the past few years.

    I myself am looking forward to the next act in the KXL circus. I sincerely hope that the issue bites McConnell and the Repugnants on the rear end, and that the Kochs take a well deserved beating $$$-wise. Both things happening would prove that there is still some sanity left in the world.

Leave a Reply to dumboldguy Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: