Rivers Key Factor in Arctic Ice Loss

March 6, 2014

Maybe a wild card in explaining years of big ice loss in the arctic.

Science Daily:

A research team led by Son Nghiem of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, Calif., used satellite data to measure the surface temperature of the waters discharging from a Canadian river into the icy Beaufort Sea during the summer of 2012. They observed a sudden influx of warm river waters into the sea that rapidly warmed the surface layers of the ocean, enhancing the melting of sea ice. A paper describing the study is now published online in the journal Geophysical Research Letters.

This Arctic process contrasts starkly with those that occur in Antarctica, a frozen continent without any large rivers. The sea ice cover in the Southern Ocean surrounding Antarctica has been relatively stable, while Arctic sea ice has been declining rapidly over the past decade.

“River discharge is a key factor contributing to the high sensitivity of Arctic sea ice to climate change,” said Nghiem. “We found that rivers are effective conveyers of heat across immense watersheds in the Northern Hemisphere. These watersheds undergo continental warming in summertime, unleashing an enormous amount of energy into the Arctic Ocean, and enhancing sea ice melt. You don’t have this in Antarctica.”

nsidc0306

Meanwhile, the ice sets up for melt season from a very low starting point.

The team said the impacts of these warm river waters are increasing due to three factors. First, the overall volume of water discharged from rivers into the Arctic Ocean has increased. Second, rivers are getting warmer as their watersheds (drainage basins) heat up. And third, Arctic sea ice cover is becoming thinner and more fragmented, making it more vulnerable to rapid melt. In addition, as river heating contributes to earlier and greater loss of the Arctic’s reflective sea ice cover in summer, the amount of solar heat absorbed into the ocean increases, causing even more sea ice to melt.

To demonstrate the extensive intrusion of warm Arctic river waters onto the Arctic sea surface, the team selected the Mackenzie River in western Canada. They chose the summer of 2012 because that year holds the record for the smallest total extent of sea ice measured across the Arctic in the more than 30 years that satellites have been making observations.

The researchers used data from satellite microwave sensors to examine the extent of sea ice in the study area from 1979 to 2012 and compared it to reports of Mackenzie River discharge. “Within this period, we found the record largest extent of open water in the Beaufort Sea occurred in 1998, which corresponds to the year of record high discharge from the river,” noted co-author Ignatius Rigor of the University of Washington in Seattle.

The team analyzed data from the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) instrument on NASA’s Terra satellite to examine sea ice patterns and sea surface temperatures in the Beaufort Sea. They observed that on June 14, 2012, a stretch of landfast sea ice (sea ice that is stuck to the coastline) formed a barrier that held the river discharge close to its delta. After the river water broke through the ice barrier, sometime between June 14 and July 5, the team saw that the average surface temperature of the area of open water increased by 11.7 degrees Fahrenheit (6.5 degrees Celsius).

“When the Mackenzie River’s water is held back behind the sea ice barrier, it accumulates and gets warmer later in the summer,” said Nghiem. “So when it breaks through the barrier, it’s like a strong surge, unleashing warmer waters into the Arctic Ocean that are very effective at melting sea ice. Without this ice barrier, the warm river waters would trickle out little by little, and there would be more time for the heat to dissipate to the atmosphere and to the cooler, deeper ocean.”

“If you have an ice cube and drop a few water droplets on it, you’re not going to see rapid melt,” said co-author Dorothy Hall of NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Md. “But if you pour a pitcher of warm water on the ice cube, it will appear to get smaller before your eyes. When warm river water surges onto sea ice, the ice melts rapidly.”

Nghiem’s team has linked this sea ice barrier, which forms recurrently and persistently in this area, to the physical characteristics of the shallow ocean continental shelf, and concludes the seafloor plays a role in delaying river discharge by holding the barrier in place along the shore of the Mackenzie delta.

The team estimated the heating power carried by the discharge of the 72 rivers in North America, Europe and Asia that flow into the Arctic Ocean. Based on published research of their average annual river discharge, and assuming an average summer river water temperature of around 41 degrees Fahrenheit (5 degrees Celsius), they calculated that the rivers are carrying as much heat into the Arctic Ocean each year as all of the electric energy used by the state of California in 50 years at today’s consumption rate.

7 Responses to “Rivers Key Factor in Arctic Ice Loss”


  1. Antarctica is also a lot colder, because it does not get as much sunlight. I’m sure that most readers of this site know this, but it cannot hurt to mention why the situation in the Antarctic doesn’t offset/cancel what is happening in the Arctic.

    • Andy Lee Robinson Says:

      I’m not sure that is totally true Neil.
      Antarctica receives more sunlight because Earth is closer to the sun in its summer and it is a miles-high desert.

      However, less is absorbed – lots of clean snow at high altitude reflects the sunlight more efficiently, and there isn’t much atmosphere to provide a significant greenhouse effect, especially with an ozone hole.
      Over the continent, sunlight basically does an in and out without doing much.

      In winter, it doesn’t make much difference how far away the sun is because it gets little or no daylight and the ice is closer to space.

      In the Arctic, the sea ice is just a thin skin at sea level with a thick atmosphere on a warm ocean and when it thins and melts, its albedo drastically changes leading to more heat absorption in summer.

      It is also more vulnerable to weather conditions as a bigger water cycle distributes more heat, and a thicker atmosphere provides a greater greenhouse effect to limit heat loss in winter.
      Heat loss is limited by clouds and snow on the ice in winter, and may carry over to the next year where more ice may melt than can be replaced on average.

      • dumboldguy Says:

        True enough, but for me the operative part of what neil said was “…the situation in the Antarctic doesn’t offset/cancel what is happening in the Arctic”. Some very bad things may happen in Antarctica before too long, but the Arctic is where it’s all happening RIGHT NOW, and all the graphics of ice extent and temperature are getting downright scary.

        (I wonder if the Las Vegas bookies are taking bets on when we’ll have an ice free Arctic? Anyone know?)

    • greenman3610 Says:

      arctic ice loss has big effect because open water increases most precisely during the times of strongest insolation.

  2. redskylite Says:

    Interesting piece from abc on the “Chasing Ice” team setting up their equipment in the Antarctic:

    http://abcnews.go.com/International/video/capturing-melting-ice-glaciers-antarctica-22791324


  3. And also a new theory for the antarctic: “a new study has pinpointed another culprit: melting ice shelves. As ice shelves that ring the southernmost continent disintegrate in warming temperatures, the fresh water that flows from them accumulates in a cool and fresh surface layer on top of the ocean. This cool layer then shields the surface ocean from the warmer, deeper waters that are melting the ice shelves.”


  4. […] 2014/03/06: PSinclair: Rivers Key Factor in Arctic Ice Loss […]


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: