More on March Extremes

March 21, 2013


Forecast sea level pressure departures from average from the GFS computer model. This shows the large area of unusually high atmospheric pressure over Greenland.
Image from Weatherbell

Although it’s still early to say that this is pound-on-the-table settled science – the most recent research suggesting a link between newly open arctic water and changes in the jet stream does seem to be one of the most compelling and interesting explanations for the wild swings in weather extremes that the planet has experienced in recent years.

I’ve posted Jennifer Francis’ lecture on this, as well as my interview from last fall,  – check those for background if you haven’t yet, – and yesterday I made the point about the forces responsible for the difference between last march, and this march in North America. Today Andrew Freedman drills deeper.

Andrew Freedman for Climate Central:

Last March, the U.S. was basking in a heat wave that drove temperatures into the 70s all the way to the Canadian border, as winter snows rapidly retreated and flowers bloomed. Unaware of the devastating drought to follow, the warmth prompted farmers all across the nation to plant their crops several weeks early, and a record corn harvest was predicted.

Fast forward to March 2013 and millions of Americans are shivering as an unrelenting string of winter storms have brought heavy snow from the Midwest to the Northeast, and colder-than-average temperatures to much of the East since February.

The past two days have provided the perfect example of that weather. On Tuesday, heavy snow fell across much of New England, bringing a foot or more of snow. That after Monday’s nasty wintry mix of snow, sleet, and freezing rain pelted New Yorkers.

To put that weather in context, consider that by March 19, 2012, more than 2,200 warm-temperature records had been set or tied across the U.S. That is about 1,000 more than had been set or tied so far this March.

Perhaps no other location best illustrates the whiplash between March 2012 and March 2013 than International Falls, Minn., known as the “Icebox” of the nation. On March 18, 2012, International Falls recorded a high temperature of 79ºF, which was a monthly all-time high.

And what was the high temperature in International Falls on Monday? A chilly 28°F, with a low of 14°F. It was even colder on Tuesday, with the forecast high temperature of just 16°F.

A similar reversal is occurring in Chicago, where the first day of spring last year brought a high temperature of 85°F, which was a monthly record. This year? Try 60-degrees cooler, with a forecast high on Wednesday of just 25°F.

The weather pattern that is responsible for this year’s cold weather is unusual, even though it is not yielding extremely cold temperatures across the U.S. In fact, March is running near average for the lower 48 states. Still, after last year’s nonexistent winter and downright summer-like spring, any cold and snow in March may seem like a shock to the system.

The weather map across the Northern Hemisphere features a sprawling and unusually strong area of High pressure over Greenland that is serving as an atmospheric stop sign, slowing weather systems as they move from west to east, and allowing storms to deepen off the eastern seaboard and tap into more cold air than they otherwise might have.

That is not your typical fair weather area of High pressure, either. Some computer models have been projecting that, sometime during the next couple of days, the Greenland High could come close to setting the mark for the highest atmospheric pressure ever recorded.

The blocking pattern has helped direct cold air into the lower 48 states as well as parts of Europe, while the Arctic has been experiencing dramatically warmer-than-average conditions, particularly along the west coast of Greenland and in northeastern Canada. Blocking patterns are often associated with extreme weather events, from heat waves like the one that occurred last March, to historic cold air outbreaks and blizzards.

A similar blocking pattern was in place at precisely the wrong time in October 2012, as Hurricane Sandy made its way northward from the Caribbean. The convoluted jet stream pulled Sandy westward into New Jersey, with devastating results. Some researchers have hypothesized that this blocking pattern was related to Arctic climate change.

One way to view the blocking pattern is through the lens of the  Arctic Oscillation, or AO, which is a large-scale variation in surface air pressure between the Arctic and the mid-latitudes. When the AO is in a negative phase, the average surface air pressure is above average in the Arctic and below average in the mid-latitudes. This sets up opposing temperature patterns, with warmer-than-average conditions in parts of the Arctic, and cooler-than-average conditions in parts of North America and Europe. Right now the AO index is at its lowest reading of anytime during the 2012-2013 winter.

Arctic climate change fingerprints?

Recent research suggests that rapid Arctic climate change, namely the loss of sea ice cover, may be contributing to blocking patterns like we’re seeing right now. That rapid decline in Arctic sea ice since the beginning of the satellite record in 1979 may be altering weather patterns both in the Far North and across the U.S.. Some studies have shown that sea ice loss favors atmospheric blocking patterns such as the pattern currently in place, while others have not shown statistically significant changes in blocking patterns across the Northern Hemisphere, at least not yet. Arctic sea ice extent declined to a record low during the 2012 melt season.

study published in 2012 showed that by changing the temperature balance between the Arctic and mid-latitudes, rapid Arctic warming is altering the course of the jet stream, which steers weather systems from west to east around the northern hemisphere. The Arctic has been warming about twice as fast as the rest of the Northern Hemisphere, due to a combination of human emissions of greenhouse gases and unique feedbacks built into the Arctic climate system. The jet stream, the study said, is becoming “wavier,” with steeper troughs and higher ridges.

A new study published in the journal Environmental Research Letters shows that reduced sea ice cover can favor colder and stormier winters in the northern midlatitudes.

As sea ice melts, it exposes darker ocean water, which absorbs more of the sun’s heat, causing the water temperatures to increase. During the fall, the heat that was added to the oceans gets released into the atmosphere as sea ice reforms, and this added heat is bound to change weather patterns somehow (this is a process known as “Arctic Amplification”). The “how” part is what’s open to debate.

Researchers examining the possible links between Arctic warming and the weather in the U.S., Europe, and other areas must contend with the large amount of natural variability that affects winter weather patterns, and the very short observational record of how the atmosphere responded to extreme losses of sea ice. In addition, climate models actually show a reduction in blocking patterns in the Northern Hemisphere, rather than the increase that one would expect given a warming planet with less Arctic sea ice. However, the models may not be capturing blocking well at the present time, let alone the future.

18 Responses to “More on March Extremes”

  1. “… due to a combination of human emissions of greenhouse gases and unique feedbacks built into the Arctic climate system.” :
    “In addition to the humanmade contribution to the sea ice loss, there are also natural factors contributing to this loss.”

    “Because the simulations do not show similar behaviour, we interpret that changes in the ice export [probably decided] is not governed by external forcing, such as changes in the CO2 concentration or changes in the incoming sunlight. The ice export is rather controlled by internal climate variability within each model, for instance, variability in the wind pattern over the Arctic.”

    • greenman3610 Says:

      the first paragraph of your reference states:
      ” In addition to the manmade contribution to the sea ice loss, there are also natural factors contributing to this loss.”
      It would be indeed surprising if this were not the case. The study does not dispute anthropogenic effects. In any case, “natural factors” such as this would have to be small enough, or rare enough, that they have not cause a substantial drop in ice during the last 1450 years.
      see Kinnard et al discussed here

    • ontspan Says:

      Yeah, typical denier trick: Cherrypick a quote from a study that can give the wanted suggestion, disregarding the overall results from the same study that show the opposite.

  2. […] Although it's still early to say that this is pound-on-the-table settled science – the most recent research suggesting a link between newly open arctic water and changes in the jet stream does seem…  […]

  3. […] last Winter in North-West Europe has been ‘interesting’, to say the least!  A follow-up to that Climate Crock’s essay […]

  4. Do we know what the high pressure over Greenland is doing – what are the temperatures there?


    • rayduray Says:

      Re: “Do we know what the high pressure over Greenland is doing – what are the temperatures there?”

      A couple days ago towns on the west side of Greenland had temperatures up to 40 C. above normal. The UK has gotten a tremendous late winter storm with flooding in Cornwall as unseasonable snow in Wales and up into Scotland. The U.S. East Coast and Canadian Maritimes are getting buffeted by a continuing series of show storms.

      Not entirely related, there are vast polynyas opening up earlier than anytime on record in the Arctic above Alaska and Canada.

      Meteorologists are noting that the weather in 2012 and 2013 are remarkably dissimilar.

      Fruit orchardists in the Midwest and Canada are grateful that March did not provide a false spring this year. The fruit crop should retutn to normal in 2013 after the disasterous harvest in 2012.

  5. Given that the weather is so puzzling, I really don’t see how anyone can predict it fifty years out.

  6. astrostevo Says:

    Heard on the radio this morning (my time) that Adelaide has had 12 days over thirty degrees (Celsius) this March so far. The average is only eight.

    Which when you think about means we’ve gone from just over one week of thirty plus on average to nearly two weeks – half the month – this year & tomorrow is forecast to reach 36 degrees C.

    See also :

    for more on our record breaking summer down under.

Leave a Reply to greenman3610 Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: