Heartland Panics Over Leak: 71 Year Old Vet, Young Mom Fire Back at Threats

February 20, 2012

Clearly in a panic over the fallout from last week’s leak of internal documents, the Heartland Institute has gone to the dependable “Plan B” of authoritarians everywhere. Threats and bullying.

A number of bloggers have now received threatening but impotent messages from Heartland thugs, including 71 year old Air Force Vet and journalist, and a young activist Mom. See their responses below.

The Recorder Online:

When I read the original articles on the release of confidential documents from the Heartland Institute board meeting, (see They’re Coming for Your Kids)  I was infuriated.

I reacted by sending a strongly worded email to the president and all the board members of the Heartland Institute.

Surprisingly, one board member and institute president Joseph Bast responded to my email.

Bast’s response is one that I would consider threatening. He said he was turning the email over to their legal department, the forensic staff and the FBI. He also warned me not to delete any emails.

Apparently, I was supposed to be frightened by the specter of this multimillion dollar non-profit (?) spending resources on an old veteran. The whole idea seems ludicrous and they know it. Still, I am not afraid of the battle if it comes. This is a tactic that big money often used to suppress free speech. See Gleen Greenwald’s article in Salon “Billionaire Romney donor uses threats to silence critics.”

During my career I have been in position for many sensitive positions and have had top secret clearances, I have been investigated by the Civil Service Commission, the FBI and the Air Force Office of Special Investigations. I feel secure that the government knows who I am.

I decided to publish these emails so that you can judge the exchange for yourself.

From: Gary Wamsley [mailto:editor@berthoudrecorder.com] 
Sent: Friday, February 17, 2012 5:16 PM
To: Joseph Bast
Subject: Heartland Institute disinformation campaign

You should be ashamed of yourself. The United States already has a problem in keeping up with the rest of the world in science education and now you want to play a role in further destroying our nation as well as our planet.

You are a traitor to your own country. I did not spend 30 years in the military to protect the likes of you.

Gary Wamsley
Colonel, USAF, Retired

From: Joseph Bast <JBast@heartland.org>
Date: Sat, 18 Feb 2012 09:46:00 -0600
To: Gary Wamsley <editor@berthoudrecorder.com>
Cc: Jim Lakely <JLakely@heartland.org>
Subject: RE: Heartland Institute disinformation campaign

Mr. Wamsley,

I assume your intemperate comments are based on a forged memo that misrepresents our efforts in the area of  global warming research education, so let me explain before demanding an apology.

The Heartland Institute is a 28-year-old national nonprofit research and education organization. We produce top-quality research and commentary on a wide range of topics, including school reform, health care,  budget and tax issues, and environmental regulation. More than 100 academics and 200 elected officials serve on advisory boards, helping to write our publications and review our work. More than 1,800 individuals, foundations, and corporations contribute voluntarily to support our work.

Last week, someone stole some documents from us and forged a memo claiming to state our ‘strategy” on global warming. See our statement in response to this attack here: http://heartland.org/press-releases/2012/02/15/heartland-institute-responds-stolen-and-fake-documents .

The Heartland Institute has never tried to “dissuade teachers from teaching science, “undermine” any other sources of research, or “keep opposing voices out” of the debate over global warming. In fact, our goals and activities are just the opposite: We have helped thousands of teachers upgrade the ratio of science to rhetoric in their classes on climate change. We have complied two hefty reports – one 800 pages long and another 400 pages long – summarizing peer-reviewed literature on climate change. We have sought to promote debate and a free exchange of ideas, despite efforts by the most alarmist voices in the debate to try to shut down discussion and ruin the reputations of any who doesn’t toe the ideological line of a small but politically powerful faction of the global science community.

The forged memo has been quoted in scores of articles and hundreds of blog posts. We are working to get those statements removed and retracted. Meanwhile, and regrettably, many people like you are being misled about our work and intentions.

Now that you know the truth, I ask that you apologize for your intemperate and very offensive letter. Since your letter is threatening, I’ve forwarded it to our legal counsel, forensics team, and the FBI. It is important that you not delete the email from your sent file, or any other emails you may have exchanged with other people while preparing it, since this could be evidence in criminal and civil cases.

Please write back to let me know if you will comply with my requests.

Best regards,

Joseph Bast
The Heartland Institute

One South Wacker Drive #2740
Chicago, IL 60606
Phone 312/377-4000
Email jbast@heartland.org
Web site http://www.heartland.org

From: Gary Wamsley [mailto:editor@berthoudrecorder.com] 
Sent: Saturday, February 18, 2012 10:46 AM
To: Joseph Bast
Subject: Re: Heartland Institute disinformation campaign

Dear Mr. Bast,

Your threatening letter only serves to reinforce my opinion that the documents are in fact all true. Your ludicrous claim that my letter is threatening is a bullying tactic to which I will not succumb. No apology is offered. I do keep my emails for six months before deleting them.

Gary Wamsley
Colonel, USAF Retired

From: Joseph Bast <JBast@heartland.org>
Date: Sat, 18 Feb 2012 11:26:18 -0600|
To: Gary Wamsley <editor@berthoudrecorder.com>
Cc: Jim Lakely <JLakely@heartland.org>, Maureen Martin <martinlaw@charter.net>, “Michael P. Padden” <mpadden@lplegal.com>, William Cook <wcook@mcguirewoods.com>

Subject: RE: Heartland Institute disinformation campaign

Mr. Wamsley,

Thank you. This is very useful.

Joseph Bast
The Heartland Institute

One South Wacker Drive #2740
Chicago, IL 60606
Phone 312/377-4000
Email jbast@heartland.org
Web site http://www.heartland.org

From: Gary Wamsley [mailto:editor@berthoudrecorder.com] 
Sent: Saturday, February 18, 2012 01:01 PM
To: Joseph Bast
Subject: Re: Heartland Institute disinformation campaign

You’re welcome.

In my opinion you have handled this whole situation quite poorly. Your original letter of Feb. 15 was almost surreal in its content and did not inspire confidence in its truthfulness, especially when compared to your actions in publishing out of context emails in what became known as ClimateGate. Did you wait to try to get verification from the scientists in East Anglica?

Your response to me would been better served by referencing articles like Megan Mcardle’s well written piece in the Atlantic or Anthony Watts in WUWT, both of which conclude that the board memo is a probably a fake.

Perhaps you responded as you did because my email angered you. I will admit that had I not been so angry when I wrote, that I might have been a bit more restrained. Please do not take this as an apology.

Gary Wamsley
Colonel, USAF Retired

Note: The following email was sent twice, but does not show up in my “sent” folder. I am unable to assertion that Mr. Bast and his associates received it.

From: Gary Wamsley [mailto:editor@berthoudrecorder.com] 
Sent: Sunday, February 19 , 2012

To: Joseph Bast

Subject: Re: Heartland Institute disinformation campaign

Cc: JLakely@heartland.orgmartinlaw@charter.netmpadden@lplegal.comwcook@mcguirewoods.com

Dear Mr. Bast, et. al.

It occurred to me that you will need my address in case you wished to pursue legal action against me.

My home address is:

Col Gary Wamsley
(address withheld here – Peter)

Just to make sure my emails are readily available to you, I am posting them on my web site. You will find them at this link

Heartland Institute threatens 71-year-old veteran


Gary Wamsley
Recorder Online

Heartland, which still hasn’t had time in their busy fundraising schedule to actually verify their claim that a single document out of dozens is a fake, still had time to threaten this young Mother — who wasn’t buying it either.

350 or Bust: 

The Heartland Institute is attempting damage control after the DeSmogBlog revealed confidential documents about the institute’s funding and its strategies to insinuate its anti-science agenda into our children’s education and undermine the IPCC . Although the Heartland Institute applauded the illegal release of thousands of personal emails stolen from Climate Research Unit at the University of East Anglia in 2009, its reaction to last week’s release of documents that one of its own staff circulated is markedly different. In fact rather than celebrating this incident which allows the general public, along with reporters and other opinion leaders to, as its president Joe Bast wrote after the 2009 emails were published, “take a serious look at the skeptics’ case in the global warming debate” the Heartland Institute is threatening to sue bloggers who have posted links to the documents, or even (see below) links to blogs or web pages discussing the documents. So much for the First Amendment.

The folks at the Heartland Institute are all for freedom of speech when it comes to bashing climate scientists and quoting out of context from illegally obtained emails, but no so much when the tables are turned and their information intended for private consumption becomes public. They even threaten mothers like me, who blog because climate change is a threat to our children’s future, and who don’t  make one red cent off of it. Mr Jim Lakely, Heartland’s communications director, communicated this to me today:

By e-mail to: 350orbust@gmail.com

350 or Bust

Re:      Stolen and Faked Heartland Documents


It has come to our attention that your blog or web site has taken one or more of the following actions:

– Posted links to a document titled “Confidential Memo: 2012 Heartland Climate Strategy.”

– Posted links to certain other documents purporting to be those of The Heartland Institute.

– Posted blogs or web pages discussing any or all of these documents.

Please be advised that the Confidential Memo is fake. It was not written by anyone associated with Heartland. It does not express Heartland’s goals, plans, or tactics. It contains several obvious and gross misstatements of fact. Publication of this falsified document, or blogs or web pages about it, is improper and unlawful.

As to other documents purported to be authored by Heartland, we are investigating how they came to be published and whether they are authentic or have been altered or fabricated. Several of the documents say on their face that they are confidential documents and all of them were taken from Heartland by improper and fraudulent means. Publication or republication of any and all confidential or altered documents is improper and unlawful.

Furthermore, Heartland views the malicious and fraudulent manner in which the documents were obtained and/or thereafter disseminated, as well as the repeated blogs or web site posts about them, as providing the basis for civil actions against those who obtained and/or disseminated them and wrote about them. Heartland fully intends to pursue all possible actionable civil remedies to the fullest extent of the law.

Therefore, we respectfully demand: (1) that you remove links to these documents from your blog or web site; (2) that you remove all posts that refer or relate in any manner to these documents or quotes from them; (3) that you publish retractions of prior postings; and (4) that you remove all such documents from your server, if you have placed them there.

Please don’t hesitate to contact me if you require any further information.

Very truly yours,

Maureen Martin

General Counsel

I’ve forwarded the email to those who are more familiar with the law than I am and I haven’t heard back from them yet. However, I have checked out what other people on the internet are saying about the Heartland Institute’s bullying tactics, and it seems the consensus is that they don’t have a leg to stand on.

Techdirt put it this way:

Now, I don’t care what you think of Heartland, climate change or anything along those lines. Whether you think it’s a wonderful organization or an evil organization… one thing I would hope we could agree on is that threatening people for “commenting” on documents with legal action, even if the documents later turn out to be fake, is not a good idea. I can certainly understand the temptation to try to get people not to comment, but the threat is pretty clearly bogus. The documents — and the leak of the documents — even if faked or altered, are still a public interest issue, and it’s hard to see how there’s any law broken in commenting about what’s in the documents. There may be legal issues for whoever leaked the documents, but those who are commenting on them? Sorry, that’s just silly.

In the meantime, I have something to communicate back to Mr. Lakely, who is co-director of Heartland’s Center on the Digital Economy as well as its communications director. I’m 350orbust’s Communications Director and I can be very economical with my digital communication, but I will let this young woman standing up for democracy and freedom speak for me:


27 Responses to “Heartland Panics Over Leak: 71 Year Old Vet, Young Mom Fire Back at Threats”

  1. The wonderful photo, alas, is evidently photoshopped: http://googlefans.goblocksite.com/archives/ahmadinejad-get-finger-2.html . Excellent blog, though, thanks for reposting.

  2. guylacrosse Says:

    Do they think they are the only people with lawyers? It wouldn’t surprise me to see a group file a civil suit against them.

    • greenman3610 Says:

      given their history with tobacco, and the precedent of the tobacco lawsuits they would make a good test case for a class action suit.

  3. As far as I’m concerned, Heartland folks can all go to h-e-double-hockeysticks (pun intended). And they can take their corporate benefactors with them!

  4. Tyson Adams Says:

    Ahhh money. Heartland is clearly rolling in far too much of it and the oil it was covered in has stained their judgement.

    I had one of my posts on The Conversation removed for commenting upon Anthony Watt’s involvement and payments in this scandal. The denier movement are quick to hide behind lawyers and threats, always a sign of someone trustworthy.

  5. daveburton Says:

    If Wamsley were a decent sort of fellow, he’d have apologized for believing the forged document, for jumping to a conclusion which wrongly assumed the worst about Heartland, and (of course) for accusing them of treason, of destroying our nation, and of destroying the planet. Really, after tossing off such outrageous insults, the surprising thing is that the reply he received from Bast was as gentle as it was.

    And if Wamsley were a decent sort of fellow he’d show some gratitude to Heartland and their donors for the wonderful work they do, which benefits all Americans.

    It is unsettling to think that a guy so gullible and so intemperate actually made it to Colonel in the USAF.

    • guylacrosse Says:

      The “wonderful work they do?” What have you been smoking?

      • greenman3610 Says:

        too funny.
        “wonderful work they do!”

        selling addictive poisons to children makes you a hero of freedom.
        as far as “gullible”, burton should again take a look in a mirror.

    • MorinMoss Says:

      If you want to decry “gullible and intemperate” people rising to the top, I believe there are many people who have far more influence than a retired colonel.

      I don’t recall anyone at Heartland showing the same restraint they demand of the public during the 2 Climategate incidents.

      Here’s an excerpt from Paul Chesser’s “Elsewhere in the Enviro-Activist Mediasphere”, dated Nov 21, 2009


      “Not bad, I guess, for a getaway Friday — but points deducted, Juliet, for accepting at face value the CRU/alarmist assumption that it was a hack job. Very well could have been an insider with a conscience.”

      An insider with a conscience – what he thought was hindsight may unwittingly have been prophecy. How ironic.

  6. So is this daveburton guy being paid by some fascist organization to spend his days posting contrarian comments on any and all website that communicate the insights offered by real climate scientists? A professional water muddier? All I know is that he makes my a-s numb.

  7. rpauli Says:

    Heartland is practicing information terrorism.

    This curmudgeon joining the fray – I posted my rant at http://heatland.org/

    “By doing the bidding of the carbon fuels industry, the Heartland Institute damages the future of all people by promoting delusional thinking on climate science. The act of planting false science, promoting shill data gathering is a form of information terrorism that encourages self-destructive behavior world-wide. Denial of global warming harms the future of our children.”

  8. http://heartland.org/issues/environment

    “The Heartland Institute’s Center on Climate and Environmental Policy produces an ambitious program of research and educational projects in defense of free-market environmentalism…. The environmental movement needs voices devoted to sound science and market-based, rather than government-based, solutions to environmental problems.”

    Instead just being a fossil fuel accomplice, Heartland could propose an alternative free-market approach – such as ending fossil fuel subsidies, replacing the payroll tax with a carbon tax, and maybe even propose a consumption tax (VAT). Or is that not “market-based”?

    • rpauli Says:

      Healthy capitalism needs science, not ideology.

      When Heartland panders to the carbon fuel interests it is a form of capital investment risk-avoidance that is essentially anti-capitalist – just as any monopoly stifles innovation. The science says we must have non-carbon energy sources – but Heartlandish economic paranoia and delusional adherence to carbon monopoly-thinking harms the future of the world.

      It is insanely high risk to promote scientific confusion.

  9. […] Heartland Panics Over Leak: 71 Year Old Vet, Young Mom Fire Back at Threats – Climate Denial C… Rate this: Share this:TwitterFacebookPrintDiggMoreEmailStumbleUponRedditLinkedInLike this:LikeOne blogger likes this post. Tagged: carbon dioxide, climate change, Environment, fair comment, global warming, Heartland Institute, politics, public interest, science, tax-exempt status Posted in: climate change, politics ← Scientists Reply to Heartland Institute Scandal One Response “The Heartland Institute’s Toothless Lawyer Dogs&#8221 → […]

  10. kap55 Says:

    Oh let’s all hope Heartland follows through and sues everyone!

    I can hardly wait to get Joe Bast on the stand and under oath. And I can hardly wait to get the right of discovery.

    This should be good.

    C’mon, Heartland! Stop the silly little threats and start filing the lawsuits. Maybe you can do what Monckton won’t.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: