Renewables Helped France Avoid Freezing in the Dark

February 14, 2012

Paul Gipe  – Wind Works:

In a startling development widely reported across Europe in the English-, French-, and German-language press, France imported electricity to meet peak demand during a brutal cold snap February 7, 2012.

And one of the countries France imported electricity from was Germany.

Post Fukushima, Germany closed two-fifths of its nuclear reactors and there were fears that Germany would not be able to meet its own demand let alone export electricity.

Nuclear reactors provided one-fourth of Germany’s electricity before Fukushima.

Available French nuclear capacity was operating flat-out with three reactors off line. However, France’s famed nuclear fleet delivered only 60% of the 100,000 MW of peak load experienced at 7:00 pm (19:00 hours) as millions of French homeowners switched on their electric heaters.

The remainder of demand was met by oil, coal, hydro, imports from neighboring countries, and renewables.

French wind turbines produced 3,600 MW at the time, or 3.6% of demand. There is 6,600 MW of wind capacity installed in France. Thus, wind delivered 55% of its installed capacity during peak demand, indicating good but not exceptional wind in parts of France.

The amount of wind generation during peak demand was roughly equivalent to the three nuclear reactors that were not available at the time.

France imported 1,800 MW or 1,8% of peak demand from Germany. (Note that the following table is subject to change as more information becomes available.)

Both French and German grid operators noted that there was never any danger of a blackout as operators held some hydroelectric capacity on standby as an emergency reserve.

German Supply during French Peak Demand

Meanwhile, Germany was enduring the same Arctic weather as France. The sun had set so Germany’s solar photovoltaic capacity was not contributing to supply.

Winds were lighter in Germany than in France, but Germany’s fleet of 29,000 MW of wind turbines was generating 6,300 MW at the time for about 22% of their potential. Nevertheless, German wind turbines were providing 9% of total German demand, more than enough for Germany to export electricity to France.
Earlier in the day, wind and solar in Germany met nearly 12% of German demand.

It is likely that German biogas and biomass plants also contributed significantly to supply. However, the public data source, EEX Transparency Platform, does not report biogas and biomass separately from conventional generation.

Craig Morris: French power consumption exceeds 100 GW— Eleven months ago, when Germany shut down 40 percent of its nuclear power capacity, some experts warned of blackouts in the winter, but it turns out that the German grid is one of the most stable in the region. . .

Brutal cold triggers reserve power plants–“We do not have a problem of supply, of quantity, it’s principally a question of stabilising the network,” a spokeswoman for the Germany electricity market regulator said. . . A recent study showed that Germany is now compensating for the off-line nuclear stations primarily with renewable energy: around three-quarters of the atomic gap. So although it’s been extremely cold recently, sunny weather in Germany helped fill France’s power shortfall caused by the country’s heavy dependence on nuclear energy. . .

Some Facts on the Electricity Heating Crisis in France December 2009–Two excellent documents have been released by the Association négaWatt in France. These reflect on the electricity crisis in France during a previous cold spell just prior to Christmas, 2009 caused by the unchecked growth of electric heating. . .

4 Responses to “Renewables Helped France Avoid Freezing in the Dark”

  1. Thanks for spreading this around — didn’t see some of these posts, but covered this story last week as well here:

    and another good post on it yesterday here:

    I think an even bigger story along these lines though, is that German PV is reducing the price of electricity in the country (big news):

    thanks for all the great shares. keep on keepin’ on! 😀

  2. otter17 Says:

    Germany is my favorite foreign country right now…

  3. Bruce Miller Says:

    Wind: cyclic, intermittent, but very dependable over the longer haul! We live, we learn. Humanity may need to leave the American dream illusions and retreat to sustainability and realistic lifestyles.
    Still curious though – Average American body weight of U.S. citizens versus average weight of Chinese, or Indians, for example may showcase the “Sustainability” lifestyle notions popularized by the high population counts we see today.
    A “map” of the world showing countries and average “calories consumed daily” might be informative. Add in climate allowances for colder countries and we might see an interesting statistic emerge, throw in a “Productivity per Capita” and observe the changes. Next, filter for personal wealth minus personal debt, and see if the American Dream lifestyle is or isn’t justifiable? Then to really round out the picture, add in energy consumption per capita, see how that changes the picture?
    80% of the U.S. population live within 40 miles of a uranium fissioning reactor. American reactors are storing up to four times their design capacities for humanocidal waste materials right now. No solution in sight, nothing is done to reduce accumulations. We are assured there will be no accidents in the U.S. of A. 9/11 ?
    Solar, Wind, Wave, Hydro, Tidal, Geothermal, Anaerobic sewage digestion, Bio-mass, all are environmentally friendly, they neither produce nor present any danger to human life, all are domestic, perpetual, eternal, or renewable, you pick your own favorite term! none are “owned” by others. Go figure.

Leave a Reply to Zachary Shahan (@zshahan3) Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: