Why Climate Change Denial is Like “the War on Christmas”

December 14, 2011

Wackjob right wing media manufactures imaginary story – check.

Story designed to activate reptilian fight-or-flight response in reality-challenged Fox News audience – check.

Add Religious Bigotry. Flavor with racism. Serve cold.

Raw Story: 

Conservative columnist David Frum, who was speechwriter for former President George W. Bush, blasted Fox News on Sunday for creating an “alternative knowledge system.”

In an article published by New York Magazine in late November, Frum had argued that conservative media like Fox News and talk radio “immerse their audience in a total environment of pseudo-facts and pretend information.”

In an appearance on CNN Sunday, Frum cited claims made on Fox News that President Barack Obama was proposing a “new Christmas tree tax,” something that was found by both The Florida Times-Union and PolitiFact Oregon to be not true.

“It fed into a story about this Muslim-y kind of president trying to destroy a Christian holiday,” Frum explained to CNN’s Howard Kurtz. “To make this a ground for a cultural conflict, to create a sense in large numbers of people they are being persecuted and attacked at a time when the country is in so much trouble, that’s how this thing is fed.”

“The question is what is the impact on the viewer?” he continued. “And we know, for example, that people that watch a lot of Fox come away knowing a lot less about important world events. That’s a correlation that we know.”

Crain’s Detroit Business: 

With real Christmas trees slowly losing sales ground to the artificial kind, many tree farmers were counting on a new federal program to boost business in Michigan — the third-largest producer of real trees in the nation.

They’ll have to wait at least another year.

In early November, the U.S. Department of Agriculture announced a “checkoff” program to promote sales of fresh Christmas trees. Two days later, under attack by conservative bloggers and talk show hosts, the federal agency changed its mind.

The program — similar to those promoting sales of beef, milk and other farm products — would have been funded by a 15 cent-per-tree fee collected from farms that sell 500 or more trees a year. The USDA had planned to appoint a board of industry representatives to oversee a “program of promotion, research, evaluation and information designed to strengthen the Christmas tree industry’s position in the marketplace,” the agency announced in the Federal Register.

Shortly after the USDA announced the checkoff program Nov. 8, the conservative blogosphere reacted. David Addington, vice president of the conservative Heritage Foundation, called the program “the Christmas tree tax.”

“The economy is barely growing, and 9 percent of the American people have no jobs,” Addington wrote in his blog. “Is a new tax on Christmas trees the best President Obama can do?”

Rush Limbaugh called it “Obama’s Christmas tree tax” and part of the “war on Christmas.” After the USDA put the program on hold, Limbaugh claimed credit.

The Agriculture Department isn’t killing the program, said Gwen Sparks, the department’s public affairs manager.

“USDA will delay implementation of this industry-funded program to provide consumers and other stakeholders an opportunity to better understand its nature and purpose,” she said.

Sound familiar? I thought so, too.


6 Responses to “Why Climate Change Denial is Like “the War on Christmas””

  1. otter17 Says:

    >> “The question is what is the impact on the viewer?” he continued. “And we know, for example, that people that watch a lot of Fox come away knowing a lot less about important world events. That’s a correlation that we know.”

    Holy cow. I can’t believe my eyes reading this from Frum’s words.

    • greenman3610 Says:

      Frum is pretty traumatized by the Bush debacle and his role in it.
      Rare for a Repub, he has a sense of shame.

  2. Reminds me of that Woody Allen musical “I Love You So Much” (I think was the title). Features a teenage son of two progressive parents who is a mad-dog conservative. Just doesn’t add up. One day the kid passes out. Turns out he had some kind of blockage that kept enough oxygen from getting to his brain. Once this is repaired and he recovers, he becomes a progressive as well. Perhaps something of the same with Frum?

  3. Thank Fox News and the Tea Party if Obama gets a second term. Nominate Newt and it’s guaranteed.

  4. […] The fossil-funded GOP noise machine is going all out to, as former Bush speechwriter David Frum recently observed –  “immerse their audience in a total environment of pseudo-facts and pretend […]

  5. […] Annie touches on the intriguing cultural resonances (and dissonances) between Christmas rituals and climate change: the obsessive concentration on images of ice, snow, the North Pole, the contrary images of open fires, heat, and flames and the high carbon consumerist potlatch which research suggests adds up to 650 kg of CO2 per person. Add to this narrative stew the way that the defence of Christmas against liberals has become an emerging narrative in the polarised political battle that surrounds climate change, as  described here…. […]

Leave a Reply to Climate Change Denial » Christmas Desserts in the Age of Melt Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: